Sunday, November 15, 2026

Fortress Besieged, the greatest Chinese novel of the 20th century - If the poem has any meaning, so much the worse for it

Qian Zhongshu’s 1947 Fortress Besieged is often described as the greatest Chinese novel of the 20th century.  New Directions just released a new edition of the 1979 translation by Jeanne Kelly and Nathan K. Mao.  I have read several 20th century Chinese novels over the last few years, so I had to read the greatest one.

Young Fang Hung-Chien is returning to China from Europe, where he has completed his studies, so to speak.  It is 1937, a terrible time to return to China, although I am not sure staying in Europe would have been better.  Perhaps, given the title this will be some kind of war novel.  No, not really.  The war is generally off in the distance.  The “fortress” in the novel's title is the institution of marriage – the unmarried want in, and the married want out.

Our hero, who spent his years in Europe goofing off, has bought a phony PhD from an Irish con man:

If he bought a bogus diploma and went back to dupe other people with it, wouldn’t he himself be a fraud?  But, remember, Fang had once been a philosophy major, and to a philosophy major lying and cheating were not always immoral.  (Ch. 1, 20)

He also successfully cheated the Irishman:

The incident may well mark China’s sole victory over the foreigners since she began to have foreign relations or signed her first treaty of commerce.  (Ch. 1, 21)

So Fortress Besieged is a satire of Chinese intellectualism.  It is in part, much to my surprise, a campus novel, beating by several years whichever American or European writer invented the genre there.

Besides, Fang was a Chinese major, so he couldn’t be too brilliant.  For in a university, science majors look down on humanities majors, foreign language majors on Chinese majors, Chinese majors on philosophy majors, philosophy majors on sociology majors, and sociology majors in turn on education majors.  Since education majors have no one to look down on, they can only despise the professors in their own department.  (Ch, 3, 105)

The precise hierarchy may be different in another academic setting, but this should look familiar to American academics.  The character of the cheerful, weaselly university president will look highly familiar.

Where the Xiao Hong’s nightmarish Tales of Hulan River (1942) seemed like part of a quite separate tradition from the European novel, Fortress Besieged straddles the Chinese and Western novels. References are as likely to be Western as Chinese.  Qian Zhongshu knows all the techniques.  He creates original metaphors, for example:

The rain grew bolder as it fell, the drops linking together to form a thread. The surface of the river seemed to have broken out with smallpox, as countless pockmarked eddies continuously came and went.  When the rain became denser, it seemed as though hair were growing from the smooth, glossy surface of the water.  (Ch. 5, 198-9)

This passage is part of the long chapter where a group of young professors-to-be travel to a brand new university in the Chinese interior.  The journey is a mix of waiting around, bad food, worse beds, illness, and dysfunction, the Japanese invasion off in another part of the country yet disrupting the most ordinary things.  The long chapter is, as can be seen in the metaphorical language above, a classic of literary disgust.

Then we get the campus novel.  Then we end with a long chapter describing the quick, petty collapse of Hung-Chien’s marriage, which I found to be deeply unpleasant and no longer humorous.  Several novels in one.

Good thing I don’t want to marry Miss Su; otherwise, I’d have to read her book just as carefully.  (Ch. 3, 102)

See, now that is some intellectual satire (the italics represent thought).

“Then you’ve grasped the essence of the poem.  There’s no need to look for meaning.  If the poem has any meaning, so much the worse for it.” (Ch. 3, 102)

I wonder if Fortress Besieged would benefit from a new translation.  The translators solve many difficult problems, but I suspect many readers will find the English prose stiff.  Stiffer than necessary?  How would I know.  The footnotes are abundant and superb.

Qian Zhongshu survived Maoist China as a comparative scholar of classical Chinese and Western literature. He lived long enough to see Fortress Besieged become a hit television series in 1990.  I have no way to judge whether the book is the greatest Chinese novel of the 20th century.  Sure, why not.

5 comments:

  1. Sounds intriguing, but I suspect I won't get around to trying it.

    Something seems to have gone wrong with these sentences:

    Qian Zhongshu’s 1947 is often described as the greatest Chinese novel of the 20th century.

    The “fortress” in the title is the institution of marriage – the unmarried want in, and the unmarried want out.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, well, only the title of the novel, that is all that I omitted. Only that little detail.

    Thanks! Fixed up now.

    I doubt many Western readers will think it is the equal of Ulysses or whatever "greatest" novel is in their head.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This might be the only Chinese novel I've read, and my experience of it was a lot like yours, which is odd, because when I've read something you've read, you usually make me see it from an unfamiliar angle. But this time I would have chosen half of the same quotes.

    To Languagehat's point, it should be "the married want out," right?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Here's the thing: Viet people use the Sino-Vietnamese names of people/ things so I never know what Westerners are talking about when you use the English transliteration.
    So I had to look him up.
    Turns out this is Tiền Chung Thư and I've never heard of him.
    The book is Vòng đời vây bủa, which sounds slightly more familiar.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yes, "married," thanks much.

    That is amusing, about the quotes, but I suppose the likely result of writing a more review-like piece. "What is this book" was angle enough.

    To add to the linguisic confusion, the first, 1979, edition of this translation used a different romanization system, so the author is Ch'ien Chung-su. New Directions switched where Pinyin for the cataloguing and cover when they published a new edition in 2004. But the text is the same. A bit of a hash.

    ReplyDelete