Somehow with Volpone (1606) hit on a style of play that was all his. He wrote three of them, not exactly quickly, in a row. Epicœne, or The Silent Woman (1609? 1610?) is the second and, what word do I want, stupidest of them. The Alchemist (1610) is the smartest, Volpone the most balanced, so now surprise it has been the most performed. I will replace “stupidest” with “purest,” it is the comically purest, approaching a meaningless perfection.
Morose is a maniac for silence. He for some reason wants to marry if he can
only find a silent wife. His nephew, a
prankster, assisted by a couple of fellow pranksters, promises such a creature,
who of course turns out to be more than ordinarily noisy once married. Although his demand for silence is not by
itself such good satire, Morose stands in for any anti-social bully, forcing
his niche tastes and prejudices on everyone around him. So the satire is not completely meaningless,
but distant. Similarly the device of justice
by means of pranks always seems thin to me.
But once the plot really gets going, let’s say in Act III,
when Morose and the Noisy Woman are married and a variety of characters are
assembled for a party, what do I care if the interwoven series of pranks do not
mean much. Although Epicoene is
too verbal to be what I think of as a farce, it gets close, including bits
where characters are shoved into closets, and it moves fast towards a
culminating piece of fireworks that is either ingenious or contrived.
Any excuse to make a lot of noise becomes terrific comedy:
TRUEWIT. The spitting, the coughing, the laughter, the sneezing, the farting, dancing, noise of the music, and her masculine and loud commanding, and urging the whole family, makes him think he has married a fury. (IV.1, 138)
How can Morose silence Epicoene?
EPICOENE. Sure, he would do well enough if he could sleep.
MOROSE. No, I would do well enough if you could sleep. Have I no friend that will make her drunk? Or give her a little laudanum, or opium?
TRUEWIT. Why, sir, she talks ten times worse in her sleep.
MOROSE. How!
CLERIMONT. Do you not know that, sir? Never ceases all night.
TRUEWIT. And snores like a porpoise. (IV.4, 149)
We are moving towards Groucho and Chico here.
Epicoene is the only surviving play of those known to
have played in the indoor, intimate, boys’ company theaters to specifically
require a brass instrument. Isn’t that
something. But this is a noisy play.
I suppose the great limit of the play, and the great thing
about it, is that like many intricate, farcical plays it is really about
plot, not the plot of the play but “plot” as a concept. The pranksters are essentially playwrights, employing
theatrical devices to move their stories along.
Theater about theater, perhaps even about co-writers, since the three
pranksters do not trust each other with their secrets. Here are two of them:
TRUEWIT. To your places again.
CLERIMONT. I pray thee, let me be in it at the other a little.
TRUEWIT. Look, you’ll spoil all; these be ever your tricks.
CLERIMONT. No, but I could hit off some things that thou wilt miss, and thou wilt say are good ones. (IV.5, 153)
Everything above that approaches an idea about or criticism
of Jonson’s play can be found in John Dryden’s typically brilliant little piece
about it in Essay on Dramatic Poetry (1668). “The intrigue of it is the greatest and most
noble of any pure unmixed comedy in any language…” (423) and by this point
Dryden is including Molière (although I should note that the whole piece is spoken
by a character who is not exactly Dryden).
I assume a heavily adapted version of The Silent Woman
still plays well. Most of the Latin near
the end has to be cut. Tighten the first
couple of acts to get to the good stuff, if that does not ruin the pacing. Dryden again:
I will observe yet one thing further of this admirable plot: the business of it rises in every act. The second is greater than the first, the third than the second, and so forward to the fifth. There, too, you see, till the very last scene, new difficulties arising to obstruct the action of the play; and when the audience is brought into despair that the business can naturally be effected, then, and not before, the discovery is made. (426)
Text and page numbers are form the outstanding first Norton
Critical Edition of Ben Jonson’s Plays and Masques (1979), edited by
Robert M. Adams. I am sorry, but the
current edition is not as good.
Next up is The Alchemist.

No comments:
Post a Comment